No paid placements. We build reviews from published vendor pricing, verified at the source, and report even on the ones we do not earn from.
⌕

EDR vs Antivirus: Which One Does a Small Business Need?

Antivirus blocks known and suspicious files before they run; EDR (endpoint detection and response) records what happens on each device after something gets through, flags attack behavior, and lets you isolate a machine and roll back damage. For a small business the price gap is smaller than most buyers expect: Microsoft Defender for Business, which includes EDR, lists at $3.00 per user per month paid yearly, while CrowdStrike's antivirus-only Falcon Go starts at $59.99 per device per year and its EDR tier, Falcon Enterprise, at $184.99 per device per year (vendor pricing pages, checked October 19, 2026). The bigger difference is who reads the alerts.

Disclosure: SoftwareSift earns affiliate commissions from some reviewed tools. This never influences SoftwareSift's rankings, scores, or true-cost modeling.

This comparison covers what each layer does, what it costs per device at named plans, where MDR (managed detection and response) fits, and how to decide by team size and IT capacity.

EDR vs Antivirus: Quick Comparison

Criterion Antivirus (EPP) EDR MDR
Main job Block malicious files and known attack patterns Detect attack behavior, investigate, isolate, and roll back A vendor team watches EDR alerts and responds for you
Who acts on alerts Mostly automatic Someone on your side, or automation The vendor's analysts, around the clock
Example plan and list price CrowdStrike Falcon Go, $59.99 per device per year Microsoft Defender for Business, $3.00 per user per month paid yearly; CrowdStrike Falcon Enterprise, $184.99 per device per year CrowdStrike Falcon Complete, contact sales
Best fit Very small teams with simple setups Teams with an IT person or an MSP Teams with sensitive data and nobody to watch alerts
SoftwareSift verdict Necessary baseline, not enough on its own for most businesses handling customer data The practical default for small businesses on Microsoft 365 Worth pricing once a breach would cost more than the subscription

Pricing as of October 2026. Verify current pricing on the provider website before purchasing.

Antivirus: Operational Profile

Modern business antivirus, often called EPP (endpoint protection platform) or next-gen antivirus, checks files and processes against known threats and suspicious patterns and stops them before they run. Windows 11 already ships with Microsoft Defender Antivirus, which Microsoft describes as next-generation protection built into Windows devices. The antivirus vs Windows Defender comparison covers when the built-in tool is enough for a single PC.

What business antivirus adds over consumer tools is central management: one console showing which devices are protected and up to date. CrowdStrike's Falcon Go, its entry business tier, bundles next-gen antivirus, USB and removable device control, and mobile device protection at $59.99 per device per year, or $7.99 per device billed monthly.

The limitation is visibility after the fact. Antivirus answers one question: was this file blocked? It does not show what a compromised account did on the machine, which other devices it touched, or how the attacker got in. Attacks that use legitimate tools, stolen passwords, or remote access software often look like normal activity to a file scanner.

EDR: Operational Profile

EDR keeps a continuous record of activity on each device: processes started, network connections, file changes, logins. It flags sequences that look like an attack and lets an admin isolate the device from the network, kill the process, and in many products roll back changes. Microsoft describes EDR as the part of device security that spots an attack and responds.

For small businesses, Microsoft Defender for Business is the most common entry point. Microsoft's page lists next-generation antivirus, EDR with automatic attack disruption, and vulnerability management for $3.00 per user per month paid yearly, covering up to 300 users and up to 5 devices per user across Windows, macOS, iOS, and Android. It is also included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium, listed at $22.00 per user per month paid yearly. The Defender for Business cost breakdown works through the per-user math.

CrowdStrike puts EDR in Falcon Enterprise at $184.99 per device per year, which also adds threat hunting by CrowdStrike's team. Falcon Pro ($99.99 per device per year) adds firewall management to Falcon Go but does not list EDR.

The limitation is labor. EDR produces alerts, and an alert nobody reads at 2 a.m. on a Saturday does not stop anything. Automatic disruption features help, but someone still has to review incidents.

Head-to-Head: Cost at 10 People

A worked example for a 10-person office with 10 laptops and 10 phones, using list prices as of October 19, 2026:

Option How it is billed Annual list cost Includes EDR?
Microsoft Defender Antivirus (built in) Included with Windows $0 No
CrowdStrike Falcon Go $59.99 per device per year, 20 devices $1,199.80 No
Microsoft Defender for Business $3.00 per user per month paid yearly, 10 users $360 Yes
CrowdStrike Falcon Enterprise $184.99 per device per year, 20 devices $3,699.80 Yes

Per-user billing favors Defender for Business when each person has several devices; per-device billing favors teams with one device each. If the business already pays for Microsoft 365 Business Premium, Defender for Business is already included.

Head-to-Head: Who Responds

This is the criterion that decides most purchases. Antivirus mostly acts on its own. EDR needs a person to triage alerts, which in a small business usually means the owner, an office manager with IT duties, or an outside MSP. MDR moves that job to the vendor: CrowdStrike describes Falcon Complete as 24/7 expert-led managed detection and response, and SentinelOne advertises 24/7 MDR as a service. Neither vendor's pricing page lists an MDR price; both route MDR to sales.

A practical middle path for a team without IT staff is EDR with automatic responses turned on, plus email alerts to two named people. Microsoft lists automatic attack disruption as part of Defender for Business EDR, which can contain some attacks without waiting for a person. It does not replace review, but it shortens the window between detection and containment.

If an MSP already manages your devices, ask whether they monitor EDR alerts and on what hours. Many MSP contracts cover patching and help desk but not after-hours security response.

Questions to Ask Before Buying

  1. Is it billed per user or per device? Count both before comparing. A team with laptops, phones, and a shared desktop can double its device count without adding a person.
  2. Which tier actually includes EDR? Vendors often sell antivirus, firewall control, and EDR as separate tiers. At CrowdStrike, EDR appears at Falcon Enterprise, not Falcon Go or Falcon Pro.
  3. Are servers covered? Microsoft covers servers through a separate Defender for Business servers add-on, managed from the same console. Check the server line item at any vendor.
  4. How long is activity data kept? EDR is only useful for investigation if the history reaches back to when the attack started. Ask for the retention period on your plan.
  5. Who gets the alert, and when? Name the person or MSP and the hours they cover. If the answer is nobody after 6 p.m., price MDR or make sure automatic disruption is turned on.
  6. What does renewal cost? List prices above are annual commitments; confirm the renewal rate and any promotional pricing before signing a multi-year term.

When to Choose Antivirus Alone

  • If the business is 1 to 3 people on personal-grade setups with no customer payment or health data, built-in Defender Antivirus plus strong passwords and backups is a reasonable floor.
  • If nobody will ever look at a security console, paying for EDR without MDR buys alerts that go unread.
  • If devices are mostly shared kiosks or point-of-sale terminals with locked-down software, file blocking covers most of the risk.

When to Choose EDR or MDR

  • If the business runs on Microsoft 365, Defender for Business at $3.00 per user per month is the lowest-friction way to get EDR.
  • If you handle customer financial, health, or legal records, or a cyber insurance application asks about EDR, choose EDR at minimum.
  • If a day of downtime would cost more than an MDR quote, and there is no one to watch alerts nights and weekends, get MDR pricing.

For a broader view of the category, see the small business security software guide, and for a ranked list of tools, the best antivirus for small business comparison.

See the full comparison on SoftwareSift, with pricing, plan limits, and deployment notes for each endpoint security option.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between EDR and antivirus?
Antivirus blocks malicious files before they run. EDR records activity on each device, detects attack behavior that gets past file scanning, and lets an admin isolate the device and investigate. Most EDR products include antivirus as well.
Does a small business need EDR?
Most businesses handling customer data benefit from it, and it can be inexpensive: Microsoft Defender for Business, which includes EDR, lists at $3.00 per user per month paid yearly as of October 2026. Very small teams with simple setups may manage with built-in antivirus and backups.
What is the difference between EDR and MDR?
EDR is the software. MDR is a service in which the vendor's analysts watch the EDR alerts and respond for you, typically 24/7. CrowdStrike Falcon Complete is an MDR offering with quote-based pricing.
Is Windows Defender enough for a business?
Microsoft Defender Antivirus built into Windows provides next-generation antivirus, but it does not include the central management, EDR, and vulnerability management that Microsoft adds in Defender for Business.

Leave a Comment

AboutMethodologyPrivacy PolicyAffiliate DisclosureContact